Scotland Wrote Co-Design into the Law

The 2024 Visitor Levy Act gave Scottish municipalities the power to introduce a tax on paid overnight stays. But unlike most other tax laws, it requires councils to consult communities, residents and tourism businesses before introducing a tax. In this way, community consultation was built into the legal foundations for tourism tax. Yet, in Edinburgh, the process had started long before.

Edinburgh Listened for Six Years

The city opened its first consultation on local sentiments about a potential transient visitor levy in 2018, long before the 2024 Act was passed. Between November 2023 and January 2024, a second round of engagement included sessions with local community councils and a survey, which produced over 3,900 responses. Then came the formal 12-week consultation from September to December 2024. 4,517 online survey responses plus opinions shared during open drop-ins and targeted meetings across the city showed broad resident support for the tax. The levy came into force on 24 July 2026 at the rate of 5%, and is expected to raise £45-50 million a year by 2028/29.

Residents Shaped the Allocation Formula

The consultation did not just approve the levy but also set its priorities. Residents participated in deciding the revenue allocation, which now includes £5 million a year for the Housing and Tourism Mitigation Fund, to deliver 472 affordable homes by 2028/29. £2 million is earmarked for participatory budgeting and 2% will go to accommodation providers to offset the administrative cost of collecting the levy. The remaining funds will be split across three streams: 55% to city operations and infrastructure, 35% to culture, heritage and events, and 10% to destination management.

Local Communities Govern the Spend

The investment areas are governed by a Visitor Levy Advisory Forum. It seats 12 members, half of whom are representatives of community organisations; the rest represent local businesses. The main task of the body is to “fairly and accurately represent the views of the city,” as the Chair Julie Ashworth noted.[1] In addition, the £2 million reserved for participatory budgeting is invested and decided on locally, ward by ward. Residents have the opportunity to suggest project ideas, submit proposals and decide on how the funds are spent in their area.

Housing and Public Spaces are on the List

The first set of approved spending programmes, besides affordable housing, includes restoration of the city’s Leith Theatre, cleaning of public spaces, new and upgraded public toilet facilities, and improvement of public infrastructure. “These spend programmes will help us not only to sustain and enhance the things that make our city so special, but also to better manage the effects of tourism and major events on those who live here all year round,” shared the Council Leader Jane Meagher.[2]

Participatory budgeting and community consultation at this scale are a UK first for a tourism tax. Glasgow and Aberdeen have since voted to introduce their own tourism levy and more and more Scottish municipalities consider following Edinburgh’s example, where a tourist tax has become a municipal exercise in democratic design and governance.

Sources